You have saved for a down payment, organized your finances, and started looking seriously. Then another housing headline arrives: pending home sales have hit a record low.
*Market information checked November 19, 2026.*
Should you step back—or look more closely?
**For a prepared NYC buyer, slower sales can create negotiating opportunities. The opportunity depends on the particular property, its competition, and whether the purchase works within your budget today.**
The national news deserves attention. But before asking a Manhattan, Brooklyn, or Queens seller for a concession, you need to understand what is happening around that apartment.
What a record low in pending home sales actually measures
A pending sale is a home with a signed purchase contract that has not yet closed. Pending-sales reports therefore offer an early view of transaction activity.
In its [November 18 report], the National Association of REALTORS® reported that October 2026 pending sales fell **4.7% from September and 16.7% from a year earlier**. Its chief economist described two consecutive months of record-low pending contracts. [nar.realtor]
That measures contract activity within the reported series. It does not establish the discount a seller will accept.
A useful distinction: fewer transactions can reflect buyers struggling with affordability, owners withholding listings, or both. To assess bargaining power, examine how many suitable homes are available alongside how quickly buyers are purchasing them.
Why NYC buyers must look beyond the national headline
[StreetEasy’s October 2026 market report], published November 12, adds an important local qualification:
– NYC homes entering contract declined **7.9% year over year**.
– Inventory reached its **lowest October level since 2017**.
– **21% of homes sold above asking**, compared with 18.9% a year earlier.
These figures come from StreetEasy’s dataset; the national figures above come from NAR’s separate report. They describe different markets and should be read in context. [StreetEasy Blog]
**The practical implication is selective opportunity.** A national slowdown gives you a reason to investigate; the apartment’s immediate competition gives you evidence for an offer.
A newly listed, realistically priced home may attract several serious buyers. Another apartment nearby may need work, face stronger competing listings, or have an asking price that recent sales cannot support.
Treat those as different negotiating situations.
When fewer competing buyers can help your offer
Negotiating room can improve when a seller has fewer credible alternatives and your proposal solves a problem.
Start by investigating:
– **Time on the market:** How does the listing’s exposure compare with similar homes?
– **Price history:** Have reductions brought the asking price closer to comparable sales?
– **Competing inventory:** What else could you buy at the same total monthly cost?
– **Condition:** What work would you need to fund after closing?
– **Timing:** Has the seller communicated a preferred closing schedule?
These are questions to research, not proof of financial distress. A long marketing period can have several explanations.
*Hypothetical example:* Two comparable apartments are available. One has just launched and has competing offers. The other has been available substantially longer than comparable listings, needs cosmetic work, and has no competing offer disclosed.
For the second apartment, a documented renovation allowance and relevant comparable sales may support a lower proposal. Sending both sellers the same national headline offers much less guidance.
A persuasive offer connects its price to the property and explains how the buyer can complete the purchase.
Negotiate the terms that improve your actual position
Purchase price matters, but it is only one part of the agreement. Depending on the property, financing, and seller’s willingness, consider these requests:
| Possible request | Potential buyer benefit | What to confirm |
| — | — | — |
| Lower purchase price | Reduces the acquisition price and may reduce borrowing | Comparable value and the revised financing figures |
| Seller credit toward closing costs | Preserves cash otherwise needed at closing | Eligible expenses and lender limits |
| Seller-funded discount points | Can obtain a lower mortgage rate | Upfront cost, rate reduction, and expected loan duration |
| Repair work or an agreed credit | Addresses a documented condition issue | Scope, approvals, lender treatment, and contract terms |
| A mutually workable closing schedule | May make the overall proposal more attractive | Lender, attorney, building, and moving requirements |
These are possible negotiating requests, not benefits every seller must provide.
For financing covered by [Fannie Mae’s interested-party contribution rules], allowable seller contributions depend on factors including occupancy and the financing ratio. Contributions cannot replace the buyer’s required down payment or reserves. Other loan programs have their own requirements. Have your lender approve the structure before relying on a credit. [Fannie Mae]
Discount points also deserve a careful comparison. The [Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains] that points exchange an upfront cost for a lower interest rate. Ask for options with and without points, evaluated over the period you expect to keep the mortgage. [Consumer Financial Protection Bureau]
Insider Insight: Equal dollar concessions can affect your cash differently
Here is an illustrative calculation, not a loan quote.
Assume a $900,000 purchase financed with 20% down. A $15,000 price reduction brings the price to $885,000. Keeping the same financing percentage reduces the down payment by $3,000 and the loan by $12,000.
A $15,000 seller closing-cost credit at the original price could instead reduce cash due for eligible expenses by the full $15,000—if sufficient eligible costs exist and the lender approves it. The down payment and loan amount would remain based on the original price.
Other closing adjustments are excluded from this illustration.
**Practical recommendation:** Ask your lender to compare the cash needed, loan balance, and ongoing payment under each proposal. Choose the structure that best supports your finances.
A lower price still calls for building due diligence
An apartment can look attractively priced while carrying expenses that deserve close attention.
For a co-op or condo, ask your attorney and other appropriate professionals to examine available building financial statements, board minutes, offering documents, assessments, and major repair information. Confirm current monthly charges and ask about anticipated increases.
The [New York Attorney General’s buyer guidance] recommends reviewing the offering plan and consulting an attorney before signing. It also identifies board minutes and financial reports as useful sources of information about building defects and repair costs. [New York Attorney General]
Ask a direct question: **What could I reasonably need to pay after closing that the asking price does not reveal?**
Then investigate the answer. A manageable cosmetic project and an uncertain building-wide capital expense require different budgets.
Being prepared should help you evaluate those questions promptly. Keep appropriate legal review and financing protections in the negotiation.
Should you wait for mortgage rates to fall?
Waiting can be sensible if today’s payment would strain your finances, your income is uncertain, or you may move again soon.
There is also a possible trade-off: if rates fall and more buyers return before suitable inventory expands, competition could increase. That is a scenario to consider, not a forecast.
Compare two workable choices:
1. Purchase a suitable home at an affordable current payment, after careful review.
2. Continue renting while strengthening savings and monitoring properties that meet your needs.
Either can be reasonable. The weak plan is buying something you can afford only if refinancing becomes available later.
The [CFPB cautions that refinancing is never guaranteed]. Changes in income, property value, and interest rates can affect whether it is possible or beneficial. [Consumer Financial Protection Bureau]
Your budget should work with the mortgage you take at closing.
Five steps before making your next offer
1. **Set your full budget.** Include mortgage payments, applicable property taxes, maintenance or common charges, insurance, known assessments, closing expenses, and reserves. Avoid double-counting costs already included in co-op maintenance.
2. **Update your financing.** Review documentation with your lender and ask about the specific property or building, proposed credits, and conditions still outstanding.
3. **Build a relevant comparison.** Examine similar recent sales, current alternatives, and available contract activity. Adjust for condition, floor, exposure, layout, and carrying costs.
4. **Choose your negotiating priorities.** Decide whether price, cash preservation, repairs, or timing matters most. Have your attorney document agreed terms.
5. **Set a walk-away point.** Establish the maximum price and unresolved risks you are willing to accept before negotiations become emotional.
National headlines can open a useful conversation. The stronger buying decision comes from preparation, property-level evidence, and terms you can comfortably carry.
If you are considering a NYC purchase, let’s discuss your budget, compare suitable homes, and identify where a well-supported offer may have room to work.
**Sydney Harewood**
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson · FIND Real Estate
646-535-3819 · [email protected]
[nycexclusiveapts.com]
*Your Premier Bridge to Manhattan Living & Wealth.*
Sources and further reading
– [NAR: October 2026 Pending Home Sales report], November 18, 2026.
– [StreetEasy: October 2026 NYC housing market report], November 12, 2026.
– [Fannie Mae: Interested Party Contributions].
– [CFPB: Comparing mortgage offers].
– [New York Attorney General: Before You Buy a Co-op or Condo].
*This article provides general buyer education. Obtain property-specific legal advice and lender confirmation of financing terms and allowable concessions.*
We hope you found this information helpful. If you have any other questions or need more details, feel free to contact us.








